Date: Fri, 30 Nov 2001 10:26:14 +0900 (JST) From: seki@neutrino.kek.jp To: Dave Casper <dcasper@uci.edu> cc: opc.nuint01@neutrino.kek.jp Subject: Sessions 5 and 6 of NuInt01 (Questions to Dave and Sakuda san) Message-ID: <Pine.LNX.3.95LJ1.1b3.1011130092517.1318A-100000@neutrino.kek.jp> Dave, As of now, I have little information on what has been done in your Session 5-1 "Comparison of MC Generastors" and also what will be done in the session. Because Session 5-2 "Theoretical Benchmark Calculations" and Session 6 "Pannel Discussions" follow Session 5-1, it is vital for me to find out what you are preparing to do in Session 5-1. I have failed to reach you by phone directly, and I have a little choice but sending you this e-mail. I am leaving for Japan on Dec. 6. The very points that I have to know are; 1) Are you asking the speakers in Session 5-1 to present benchmark calculations using their MC codes? 2) Are you going to discuss comparison of these benchmark calculations in your summary talk at the end of Session 5-1? I am supposed to talk on "Comparison of Benchmark Calculations" in the beginning of Session 6. I assume that I am to summarize the theoretical benchmark calculations and then to do a quick comparison of the with the MC benchmark calculations, so that we can (hopefully smoothly) move to the pannel discussions to follow. We have a little more theorists than expected, presenting benchmark calculations, and I am planning to have 20 minutes to do this "Comparison of Benchmark Calculations" talk, assuming "yes" from you to 1) and 2) above. If not, I'd need more time. Also, I'd like to have the speakers of BOTH of Session 5-1 and 5-2 to bring the transparencies of their benchmark calculations to the evening meetings of Dec. 12, so that the pannelers of Session 6 can have all results in transparencies relevant to their parts well BEFORE their talks. I really wished to be able to arrange for the panelers to have them much before Dec. 12 evening, but perhaps this is the best we could do under the circumstance. If we could not arrange this, I really think that the purposes of Session 6 would be largely lost and it might need a last minutes' reaarngement in the schedule for Session 6. 3) Can you (unless you have alredy done so) ask the speakers of Session 5-1 to bring transparencies of their benchmark MC calculations in the evening session of Dec. 12? I will ask the speakers of Session 5-2 to do the same, and will inform the pannelers of session 6 to expect to have the relevant transparencies in the evning of Dec. 12. I'd really appreciate your response, as I am, frankly speaking, not quite sure that I could carry out a responsible job as the chair of Session 6. Best wishes. Seki p.s. To: Sakuda san Above, I am assuming that we can duplicate the transparencies (including colored ones) in the evening of Dec. 12. If we cannot, we have to think of something else.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.0 : Fri Nov 30 2001 - 10:26:16 JST